A Christian Writing with Buddhists: How I am Here and What it Means to be Noble-Minded

The experience of being assigned to speak about Buddhism at a Kingdom Hall is especially important here. Witnesses have their own book about world religions called Mankind’s Search For God. There’s a chapter about Buddhism, which was supposed to be my source material. That’s how they did things. Instead, I researched pieces actually written by Buddhists about their beliefs and practices for my talk. That’s how I did things.

 

By David Jones

So why is a Christian writing articles for a Buddhist site?

It may not seem intuitive to most folks, but it’s perfectly natural for me. When I joined my first church, I learned to give sermons, and I fell in love with it. But there was one I wanted to give and wasn’t allowed to: I wanted to research and speak about…Jehovah’s Witnesses.

Within a few years, I became a Witness.

I learned more about research, public speaking and persuasive argument and I fell deeper in love with teaching. One day I received an assignment to research and speak about…Buddhism.

Some 10 years later, I’m writing with Buddhists. I’m just following my path.

The experience of being assigned to speak about Buddhism at a Kingdom Hall is especially important here. Witnesses have their own book about world religions called Mankind’s Search For God. There’s a chapter about Buddhism, which was supposed to be my source material. That’s how they did things. Instead, I researched pieces actually written by Buddhists about their beliefs and practices for my talk.

That’s how I did things.

Researching things for myself rather than relying on what others insist is correct, even if I trust and like the teacher, is my way. That’s why I identify with my heroes the ancient Bereans.

Here’s the scene: according to Acts 17, the Apostle Paul was in Thessalonica preaching about Jesus, which made a lot of people very happy and a lot of others very angry. Some became believers, while others were out to get him.

He and some companions ran away at night to the city of Berea. His teaching had similar success, with one difference: while many Thessalonians accepted Paul’s teaching automatically, the Bereans insisted on looking into the things he said for themselves.

Which brings me to the Kalama Sutta.

According to the Aṅguttara Nikaya sutta 3:65, Buddha was traveling and came to the town of Kesaputta. These folks—the Kalamas—were sage magnets, with teachers constantly showing up in town with their musings, telling everyone “my teaching is right, all those other guys are fakers.” People were understandably confused.

The Encyclopedia of Buddhism goes deep into the account, and Buddha’s reply essentially boils down to this: don’t reflexively believe a teaching for any reason. Test it in your heart, in your life, and see if the teaching is really beneficial or if it’s all just cool words. Whether it be holy writings, a disciple or Apostle, even the words of Buddha or Jesus—it doesn’t matter what the source of the teaching is or how you feel about it.

Test it out.

Blind faith in a teacher, scripture, or interpretation may be easy, but it sure ain’t healthy. It leads folks to become dogmatic, inflexible, unwilling to learn or change, and more so if they’re surrounded by people who insist their view is the only correct one.

The takeaway here, from the teaching of Buddha and the example of the Bereans, is that it’s wise to question, to put beliefs and teachings to the test, and to avoid blind acceptance (which is reflexive and completely opposite of mindful acceptance).

The Bible calls the Bereans “noble-minded” for their cautious examination. Granted, they still ended up using a holy writings as the cornerstone of their evaluation, but the point is they were specifically and directly contrasted against the example of the Thessalonians who believed Paul without personal investigation.

Interestingly, the Kalama Sutta also refers to those disciples who question and only accept teachings which promote compassion and love as “noble.” These noble disciples will evaluate teachings and reject those which lead to suffering.

So here I am, a Christian (not a model one, to be sure) who prayerfully investigates what I’m taught and tries the spirit of those teachings. (1 John 4:1) Teachings which bring about harm need to go. The Bible and the Kalama Sutta agree that the teachers and their lessons can be identified by their fruits—good or bad.

May we all seek the true and lasting benefit of others when we consider our teachings and words. And let’s be determined to reject teachings which lead only to suffering and harm to ourselves and others, regardless where the teaching came from.

That would be the noble-minded thing to do.

Photo: Pixabay

Editor: Dana Gornall

Did you like this post? You might also like:

The Bright Blue Air: Above the Fray of Religions

 By Susan Baller-ShepardThe pool at our friends' house looked inviting and blue the day our three-year-old son decided to skip his flotation vest and jump into the deep end.I was at the other end of the pool, putting sunscreen on my other son, when I saw...

The Story of the Buddha.

  By Daniel Scharpenburg A lot of you may know this story already. I think it's important for those of us that follow the path of the Buddha to reflect on his life story because he is the example we're trying to live up to. He was a normal human being, just like you...

The Poetics of Practice.

  By Bryonie Wise   The crowd falls quiet the moment I step onto my mat. Each voice in my head, each thought, each distraction is stunned into silence—they pause, waiting to see what will happen next. My toes, bright and red, shift around, as I root myself further...

Kindness as a Religion.

  By Guy Newland “My religion is kindness."This is something that the Dalai Lama repeats again and again, like a mantra, wherever he goes. The 80-year old Nobel Laureate entitled the Dalai Lama, whose actual name is Tenzin Gyatso, is the spiritual leader of Tibetan...

Comments

comments

David Jones

Columnist at The Tattooed Buddha
David Jones has a 30-year career with the United States government. He encountered mindfulness in therapy for his endangered marriage (which had led to anxiety-based depression and dissociative disorder symptoms), and writes about the experience in his blog as well as articles in various publications. He started writing articles about mindfulness for Yahoo Voices under the brand: A Mindful Guy.
(Visited 161 times, 1 visits today)