
Many practitioners will sit and believe they are doing just that—that following the breath, considering a koan, labeling thoughts, or the many other “skillful means” available will get them there. Yet, despite the many benefits that may accrue from these practices, when these practitioners talk they show that they are still stuck in the conceptual mind. Their problems, and the effect they produce, are the same as for the non-practitioner.
By Angel Roberto Puente
Dōgen Zenji (道元禅師, 1200-1253) is one of the most influential Zen teachers in the West.
He lived during a special period in world history that spanned: Japan’s medieval age, China’s Southern Song religious golden age, and the High Middle Ages in Europe. He went to China (while Genghis Khan was attacking the north of China, Dogen remained in the relatively peaceful south), because in Japan he couldn’t find the answer to the paradox:
“If all human beings are born with inherent ‘Buddha-nature’ (original enlightenment), why must we engage in rigorous, exhausting practice to achieve enlightenment?”
He realized during his four-year stay, that “practice and enlightenment are one and the same—we do not practice to attain enlightenment; practicing is the expression of our inherent ‘Buddha-nature’; the universe practices through us. He brought this radical insight back to Japan, reshaping Japanese Zen. Although he inherited the lineage of the Chinese Cáodòng tradition (Sōtō in Japan), he preferred to call his school the “Buddha School.”
He didn’t approve of sectarian labels and was very critical of those who used them. For him, those were false constructs that diluted and distorted the true, universal nature of the Buddha’s teachings.
Discussions about Dogen’s Zen manifesto, the Shōbōgenzō, abound. It is, at the same time, practical, philosophical, and poetic. It’s no surprise that so many interpretations exist.
Dogen gave the keys to interpret what he was saying:
1. Practice is enlightenment; there is no striving to become a Buddha.
2. The inherent enlightenment is not a passive state but a dynamic reality that must be actualized through continuous practice.
3. The activities of daily life are all sacred expressions of Buddha-activity if approached with complete presence and selfless openness.
Dogen’s abstruse writing can only be understood from the point of view of those who manifest this, “complete presence and selfless openness.” One of the most commented of the essays of the Shōbōgenzō is “Uji” (有時), translated as “Being-Time.” Consider this statement: “We must look on everything in this world as time… All beings are time; Buddhas are time… Not a single thing arises apart from time-being.” Also there is this poetic statement:
“For the time being, I stand astride the highest mountain peaks.
For the time being, I move on the deepest depths of the ocean floor.
For the time being, I’m three heads and eight arms.
For the time being, I’m eight feet or sixteen feet.
For the time being, I’m a staff or a whisk.
For the time being, I’m a pillar or a lantern.
For the time being, I’m Mr. Chang or Mr. Li.
For the time being, I’m the great earth and heavens above.”
I’ve read long explanations of these quotes that stay in the realm of conceptual thinking. There are no bridges offered in those writings to the “actualization” of these cryptic statements. Yet, the statements are pointing to the essence of practice. It is only from the experience of stillness that these statements made by Dogen can be understood. Only when all attachments to concepts are surrendered can we “for the time being” merge with conditions.
In another instance, Dogen explained:
“To carry the self forward and illuminate myriad things is delusion. That myriad things come forth and illuminate the self is awakening.” Always pointing to practice, he first describes how we try to understand life by thinking about it. No amount of anticipation will fully prepare us for the actual experience. Then he shows that correct direction is to function from clear, spacious awareness and let things appear and disappear in this space, so that whatever message they bring is immediate, effortless, and related to the moment.
Four centuries later, Bankei Yōtaku would echo these postulates in a less elaborate manner than that of the extensive Shōbōgenzō.
Seen from the standpoint of practice, they are completely in accord. Bankei would declare: “Abide in the Unborn” and stress that this is our natural, given condition. Easy to access, but requiring constant practice. Like Dogen’s “dynamic reality,” it is expressed in all our activities, adding a broader dimension to the word zazen, that is widely thought of as “sitting (za) in meditation.” The “za” of zazen acquires its true embodied significance as the stillness of original mind.
Dogen tells us that abandoning the unchanging, ever-present, original awareness to chase after “miriad things” is delusional.
We need to anchor the functioning of body/mind to the highest condition of awareness: to the undiscriminating consciousness. Many practitioners will sit and believe they are doing just that—that following the breath, considering a koan, labeling thoughts, or the many other “skillful means” available will get them there. Yet, despite the many benefits that may accrue from these practices, when these practitioners talk they show that they are still stuck in the conceptual mind. Their problems, and the effect they produce, are the same as for the non-practitioner.
Sitting is the pill they take to alleviate the pain.
This changes when the practice of meditation is seen as a progressive training that starts by giving awareness its place as the mediator of all experiences. As Dogen says, we are born with it; Buddha mind is everyday mind. We can easily realize this by observing the many perceptions that we are aware of without any effort on our part. This is because the original mind is clear and without boundaries. Practice aims at keeping it this way by restricting the many ways we interrupt the clarity: the ways “we carry the self forward” and illuminate myriad things, creating a false reality.
Having placed awareness in its proper place—as our unchanging self—we can then proceed to engage the body and the conceptual mind with the intention of harmonizing them.
The breath is the conduit between them. Relaxation in the body and the quiet, alert mind are affected by the quality of breathing,( a return to deep abdominal breathing; the kind observed in a newborn baby, provides the best outcome).
From the vantage point provided by this way of practice, all manner of reactions in the body and mind can be observed and understood. By letting our awareness be expansive, inclusive, and unfixated on any particular perception, the sense of “me” has nothing to grip, it dissolves. All this becomes an organic, embodied condition that is habitual.
It doesn’t depend on concepts. It’s a great way to live.
Photo: Pixabay
Editor: Dana Gornall
Did you like this post? You may also like:
Comments
- Zazen: Beyond Conceptual Mind - November 19, 2026
- Are You Enlightened? - September 28, 2026
- The Art of Attention - August 26, 2026